# How to make an ethics discussion with relations in Creaza Canvas

Put a care robot from «Content» in the middle, write arguments from consequentialism, duty ethics and virtue ethics in text boxes with «Text», and connect them to the robot with «Relation», or Alt+R (Mac: ⌥+R). Green relations strengthen human dignity, red ones challenge it.

Video: [The robot at the nursing home – Creaza Canvas](https://help.creaza.com/en/canvas/robot-at-the-nursing-home/)

## How this was made

1. The title «The robot at the nursing home» is above a care robot from «Content», or Alt+I (Mac: ⌥+I), in the middle. The question is whether the robot helps elderly people or challenges human dignity.
2. The arguments are written in text boxes with «Text», or Alt+T (Mac: ⌥+T). Each ethical theory has a small picture: scales for consequentialism, a book for duty ethics and a heart for virtue ethics. The arguments that strengthen human dignity are on one side of the robot, and the arguments that challenge it on the other.
3. With «Relation» in the toolbar, or Alt+R (Mac: ⌥+R), the robot is connected to the pictures. The relations are green with the label «strengthens human dignity» or red with «challenges human dignity», and the text boxes have the same colour. You choose the colour with «Design» in the relation's menu. Press M to go to the menu with the keyboard.
4. Consequentialism looks at the outcomes: «More people get help when there are too few carers» and «Fewer meetings with people can lead to more loneliness».
5. Duty ethics asks what we owe each other: «We have a duty to give all elderly people good and safe care» and «People are ends in themselves, not just tasks to be done».
6. Virtue ethics asks what kind of people we become: «Carers get more time to show kindness and warmth» and «What kind of carers do we become if machines take over?»
7. A carer and an elderly resident give a voice to the two sides, each in a speech bubble. The carer says: «The robot helps with lifting and reminds people about their medicine. That gives me time to sit down and talk.» The resident says: «It's nice to talk to. But I miss a warm hand to hold.»
8. Finally there is the question «Where is the line for what a robot should do?» for the class to discuss.

## Keyboard shortcuts

- Go to the menu of the selected element (Tab moves between the buttons, Esc goes back): M
- Relation: Alt+R (Mac: ⌥+R)
- Text (new text box): Alt+T (Mac: ⌥+T)
- Content (pictures, characters and backgrounds): Alt+I (Mac: ⌥+I)

## Good to know

- Choose another new technology, such as AI in school or self-driving cars, and link arguments from the three ethical theories.

## See also

- [Make a connection (relation)](https://help.creaza.com/en/canvas/create-relation/): Connect two pictures with a relation, add a label and choose the look.
- [The argument map](https://help.creaza.com/en/canvas/argument-map/): The claim in the middle, arguments in a green box and counter-arguments in a red one, each linked to a source. The map becomes the outline of a discussion text.
- [Speech bubbles in Canvas](https://help.creaza.com/en/canvas/canvas-speech-bubble/): Let characters talk to each other with speech bubbles and tails that point the right way.
- [What happens next?](https://help.creaza.com/en/canvas/what-happens-next/): A bike theft in the middle and the consequences for the individual and society, in the short and long term. The link labels tell law, rule and norm apart.

